Changes between Version 17 and Version 18 of OpenITPReview/Criteria


Ignore:
Timestamp:
May 17, 2013, 6:32:45 PM (6 years ago)
Author:
zzz
Comment:

adversaries/audience

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • OpenITPReview/Criteria

    v17 v18  
    5353=== Audience and Adversary Definition ===
    5454|| '''Criterion''' || '''Our response''' || '''Do we fulfil this?''' ||
    55 || Is the tool actively designed with the needs of at-risk users in mind? ||  || '''No?''' ||
    56 || Does the project understand who their users are? || Difficult (impossible?) to get these statistics. || ||
    57 || Does the project understand who their user's adversaries are? || See previous criterion. || ||
    58 || Is the tool actively designed with their user's adversary's capabilities in mind? || Maybe generally? || ||
    59 || Is the tool being used for contexts outside of those that it was designed for? || At least one user uses I2P as a dynamic dns with nat traversal capability ||  ||
    60 || Was the tool designed with a realistic awareness of the needs of its intended user community? || '''TODO: Check old meeting logs''' || ? ||
     55|| Is the tool actively designed with the needs of at-risk users in mind? || Yes || Yes ||
     56|| Does the project understand who their users are? || Yes, in general, however specifics are difficult to gather due to the nature of anonymity tools. ||  Yes ||
     57|| Does the project understand who their user's adversaries are? || Yes, in general, however specifics are difficult to gather. || Yes ||
     58|| Is the tool actively designed with their user's adversary's capabilities in mind? || Yes, in general, however we could always do better. || Yes ||
     59|| Is the tool being used for contexts outside of those that it was designed for? || Probably. At least one user uses I2P as a dynamic DNS with NAT traversal capability. I2P is an open source tool that is modified and packaged by several third parties. ||  ||
     60|| Was the tool designed with a realistic awareness of the needs of its intended user community? || Yes, in general. See e.g. http://www.i2p2.de/_static/pdf/i2p_philosophy.pdf and old meeting logs. || Yes ||
    6161
    6262=== Development Process Transparency ===