Changes between Version 1 and Version 2 of OpenITPReview/Criteria


Ignore:
Timestamp:
May 8, 2013, 10:13:56 AM (6 years ago)
Author:
str4d
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • OpenITPReview/Criteria

    v1 v2  
    3939|| Does the user experience compromise the secure use of the tool? ||  ||  ||
    4040|| Has there been a professional designer involved in the tool development process? ||  ||  ||
    41 || Has there been user experience testing involved in the design process and if so, what? ||  || ||
    42 || Is their a style guide or set of design guidelines for the tool? ||  || ||
     41|| Has there been user experience testing involved in the design process and if so, what? ||  || No ||
     42|| Is their a style guide or set of design guidelines for the tool? ||  || No ||
    4343
    4444=== Documentation ===
     
    6464|| Does the project plan development in public fora (such as a mailing list or IRC channel)? || Yes: IRC2P/#i2p-dev, http://zzz.i2p, http://lists.i2p2.i2p || Yes ||
    6565|| Does the project have an accurate roadmap that is up to date and has a history of use? ||  || No ||
    66 || Does the project have a public bug tracker? Has the project used their bug tracker over time and kept it accurate? || Yes - here (though not always entirely current due to small developer base) || Yes ||
    67 || Does the project have a public source repository that is in use for mainline development? ||  || ||
     66|| Does the project have a public bug tracker? Has the project used their bug tracker over time and kept it accurate? || Yes (though not always entirely current due to small developer base) || Yes ||
     67|| Does the project have a public source repository that is in use for mainline development? || Monotone - http://viewmtn.meeh.i2p/ || Yes ||
    6868|| Has the project added new developers or other volunteers over the life of the project? || Yes, though only a few long-term developers. || Yes ||
    6969
     
    9696|| Does the project have an accurate roadmap that is up to date and has a history of use? || See above. ||  ||
    9797|| Does the project have a public bug tracker? Has the project used their bug tracker over time and kept it accurate? || See above. ||  ||
    98 || Does the project have a public source repository that is in use for mainline development? || Monotone || Yes ||
     98|| Does the project have a public source repository that is in use for mainline development? || See above. || Yes ||
    9999|| Is the project documentation up to date in all the languages the project supports? || No, but the translation tagging of the website revamp will enable more accurate coverage. || No ||
    100 || Does the project have a test framework? || Both JUnit and ScalaTest || Yes ||
    101 || Does the project have significant regression testing coverage? ||  || ||
     100|| Does the project have a test framework? || Both JUnit and !ScalaTest || Yes ||
     101|| Does the project have significant regression testing coverage? || About 30% - see http://jenkins.killyourtv.i2p/job/cobertura/ || No ||
    102102
    103103=== Project Impact ===
    104104|| '''Criterion''' || '''Our response''' || '''Do we fulfil this?''' ||
    105 || How large is the project's user base? || http://stats.i2p shows ~30,000 users ||  ||
    106 || Does this project benefit an at-risk population directly or indirectly? ||  || ||
     105|| How large is the project's user base? || http://stats.i2p shows ~30,000 routers ||  ||
     106|| Does this project benefit an at-risk population directly or indirectly? ||  || Yes ||
    107107|| Are there any alternatives for this functionality on the platforms it serves? || Tor provides hidden services, but unmaintained and tangential to Tor's target functionality. ||  ||
    108108|| Is this tool recommended by trainers or others in the field? || Unknown ||  ||
    109 || How security-critical is the tool's functionality? || ||  ||
    110 || Is this project infrastructure that other tools depend on? ||  || ||
     109|| How security-critical is the tool's functionality? || Being an anonymous network, other tools are dependent on its security. ||  ||
     110|| Is this project infrastructure that other tools depend on? || Yes, e.g. eepsites, torrent software || Yes ||
    111111|| What does the project's growth curve look like? || Slow growth for the first 8 years, then large (exponential?) growth over the last few years. ||  ||
    112 || Is this tool localized for significant at-risk populations? || ||  ||
    113 || Is localization applied consistently? || ||  ||
     112|| Is this tool localized for significant at-risk populations? || We have translations for Arabic and Chinese (among others). ||  ||
     113|| Is localization applied consistently? || Localization of the routerconsole is mostly done via gettext. Inconsistencies do occur in the separate-page translations. ||  ||
    114114
    115115=== Project Auditing Need ===